Building the Ultimate Gaming PC

Written on July 7, 2003 by Jon Bach

Share:

Always look at the date when you read a hardware article. Some of the content in this article is most likely out of date, as it was written on July 7, 2003. For newer information, see our more recent articles.

Introduction

If money was not a factor, how would you design the Ultimate Gaming Computer? At Puget Custom Computers, we are asked that question quite often, so here we come with an article devoted to that subject! What makes a gaming computer great, and what should you think about when you design your own? In this article, we will answer those questions, and get you on your way to gaming paradise!

Design Priority

Force Feedback! Overall, you need to know what components of your computer are most heavily used during gaming. The order is simple, but we'll go into more detail. From most to least important, we have:

Video card
Sound card
CPU and Memory
Interface and Appearance

Video Card

With the huge complexity and intensity of graphics in today's games, it is impossible to have smooth playback without a good video card. While you can get by with a Radeon 9000 or GeForce4 MX card, these are simply cheaper alternatives to the real performers. With top notch video cards, you have a few choices, so let's give them a look:

ATI Radeon

ATI's Radeon line has been offering great gaming video cards for years. If you're looking for performance at all costs, the Radeon 9800 with 256mb memory is the leader of the line, but be warned: it isn't cheap! If you'd like to save a little money, you could grab a Radeon 9500 at less than half the price, and get the same features at a reduced performance rate. For many months, these ATI cards were able to boast their position as the only cards with full DirectX 9 support. While this doesn't mean much today, it will mean much more as more games use DirectX 9 features. In the end, DirectX 9 support means better performance with the same hardware, as game designers build visual effects onto DirectX 9 functions that are hard coded right on your video card. In short, if you are a serious gamer, if you don't have DirectX 9 support, then you should plan on needing to buy another video card in about a year! While ATI used to be the only manufacturer who could claim DirectX 9 support, we now see this same support from their main competitor - nVidia.
nVidia GeForce

Although the performance of ATI cards has had them beat for the most of last year, if only slightly at times, nVidia has always had the advantage of a more compatible and more stable card. This is mostly due to their drivers - ATI is notorious for buggy drivers. I tend to lean toward nVidia myself, because performance is worth nothing if your machine keeps crashing! For the last 10 months, the GeForce4 line has been a great line, providing innovation and great performance improvements to the industry. If you're looking to get a great card for a modest price, then the GeForce4 Ti 4200 or 4800 would be a great pick. In the last months, the new GeForceFX line has been their new flagship series. This is the new line that also boasts DirectX 9 support. Unfortunately, while I have always been a supporter of nVidia, even I have to say that the initial GeForceFX line was disappointing. The first cards to come out where huge and loud. The fans were so big that they took up two slots, and they were ridiculously loud with their oversized cooling setup. Thankfully, the manufacturers have given attention to the noise issue, and it has been significantly improved, but these cards still take up two slots, which makes them impossible to use in mini PCs. On top of these issues, we just didn't see impressive performance from them. Even the fastest GeForceFX 5800 could not beat out ATI's Radeon 9800. Then on top of that, ATI released the Radeon 9800 with 256mb memory, and further strengthened their standing. Much of this performance problem was based on a memory bottleneck, which nVidia was wise to give immediate attention. With the GeForceFX 5900, the memory bus is widened, giving the card the performance edge it needed to be competitive with ATI. So, now it is neck and neck again (as always), but the GeForceFX 5900 Ultra is the clear leader.

In the benchmarks to the right, you'll see the performance of each card in Unreal Tournament, in 1600x1200 resolution at 32bit color, with 2x FSAA. The benchmarked performance of each card highly depends on the test system specifications, and these display settings, but in the end, our choice for the Ultimate Gaming PC is clear - the GeForceFX 5900 with 256mb memory. It just doesn't get any faster!

Sound Card

While graphics is always the focus of a great gaming PC, an aspect that is often not given enough attention is the sound card. Not only does a quality sound card mean better audio quality, but without the right sound card, the performance of your system is severely impacted. Thankfully, this area is quite simple to make recommendations for - if you get a Soundblaster Audigy or Audigy2 sound card, you're in great shape. Of the two, the Audigy2 has more features and better sound quality, but you can view a full comparison chart by clicking here. In most cases, onboard sound is not a good choice, but there is one exception to this, found in the nForce2 chipsets. The nForce2 APU gives shockingly good performance and audio quality. TomsHardware.com did a review on this chipset, and found the audio performance and quality to be roughly the same as an Audigy card. Not bad for an integrated solution! On top of that, nVidia's drivers are very clean and easy to work with. Setup is a snap, and whether you're hooking up regular stereo speakers or a full digital 5.1 set, the sound control panel makes it very easy to configure and get running in no time! On a budget, the choice is clear - go with the nForce2. SoundBlaster Audigy2 We'll talk more about the advantages of the chipset next, but even for the sound alone the choice is worth considering. But as much as we like the nForce2, for the Ultimate Gaming PC, we'll use the Audigy2.

CPU and Memory

A good gaming video and sound card is useless if you don't have a good foundation to put it on. Your memory must be able to provide the bandwidth your games need to load up the next level in your game without hesitation. In the past, this choice has been tougher, with questions of RDRAM versus DDR-SDRAM. Lately, however, we see RDRAM being phased out, leaving us with a clear choice - DDR! New dual-DDR chipsets will use two DIMMs concurrently to provide even more memory bandwidth. Even though the performance advantage is smaller than you might think, it is still a good idea. The nForce2 chipset has this feature, and is basically your only choice right now if you go the AMD route. Not only does that give you the nForce2 sound system, but it gives you the dual-DDR memory benefit, and also gives you the ability to use the newest Athlon XP processors. Starting with the 3200+ processor, the Athlon XPs will run at a 200MHz FSB, and the nForce2 chipset is the only one equipped with the ability to run that fast. So, if you're going the AMD route, the Asus A7N8X-Deluxe motherboard with a Athlon XP 3200+ processor and 1.0GB of DDR400 memory is our recommendation.

CPU Benchmarks But what about the Pentium4 route? As much as us AMD buffs don't like to admit it, Intel holds onto their long standing performance lead that they reclaimed way back with their 2.53GHz processor. Even the AMD 3200+ isn't able to beat out the Pentium4 2.8GHz processor. Most recently released is the line of Pentium4 processors that run on a 800MHz FSB. Also new to the technology scene is the dual-DDR based Intel chipset. Our pick for the Ultimate Gaming PC? The Asus P4C800-Deluxe motherboard, with a Pentium4 3.2GHz 800FSB processor, and 1.0GB of DDR400 memory.

Interface and Appearance

One aspect of a gaming PC that is often overlooked is the quality of the user interface. You need a good keyboard, smooth mouse, and a responsive monitor! You'll never beat that game if your mouse ball is clogged up and you can't see through the dead pixels on your monitor! The obvious choice for your mouse is to use an optical mouse. As long as you steer away from the cheapest keyboards, you'll be fine there. Where I want to focus is on the monitor. It is always the conception in the computer industry that "more expensive is better." That just plain isn't true. The better technology is better, regardless of whether it is more or less expensive. Right now, LCD technology is quite a bit more expensive than the traditional CRT technology, but that doesn't make it better. With monitors and gaming, you need to look at the response time of your monitor. This is the time it takes one pixel to turn off, and the next to turn on. With LCD monitors, this response rate is quite slow. While that's no problem at all for word processing, email, and web surfing, this slow response rate makes for excessive flicker in games. If your monitor flickers during gaming, you've undone everything you paid for in putting together a great gaming machine that renders smooth graphics! So save yourself the money, and get a traditional CRT monitor unless your desk really is so small that you need the space saving LCD!

Lian-Li case with clear side window While the appearance of a gaming system is often the first thing an avid gamer thinks about, it clearly has nothing to do with the performance of the system. Luckily, it is quite cheap to get a great looking machine! Clear side windows, neon lights, round cables...you can often make all of those modifications to your system for under $50. If you wanted to go all out, you could use liquid cooling! However, one very important note to make here is that with all the cooling needed for the new video cards, it is nearly impossible to achieve the same level of cooling with liquid cooling. You can cool your CPU, hard drive and motherboard incredibly well, but the heat creation on the video cards is so widespread that it is impossible to cover with a standard waterblock. For this reason, we recommend staying with your standard air cooling for the video card, even if you have a liquid cooled computer. With our Ultimate Gaming PC, we use a Lian-Li PC6083 case, with a clear side window, blue neon light, and round cables. The end result is a clean look - it looks great but it isn't over the top.

Conclusion

In the end, building the Ultimate Gaming Computer is not very difficult as long as you have benchmark data available. When money is not an issue, just buy the fastest! Aside from that, upgradability and apprearance are your only more complicated concerns. For our system, we used:

Asus P4C800-Deluxe Motherboard
1.0GB PC3200 DDR-SDRAM
Intel Pentium4 3.2GHz CPU
MSI GeForceFX 5900 Ultra 256mb
SoundBlaster Audigy2

Put these components in a snazzy case, and you have yourself the best gaming PC money can buy! But who has that much to spend? If you're looking for ways to save, then buying the "next best" hardware is the best way to save. Look out for our next article, which will cover how to build a great gaming PC on a tight budget!

TheMattrix

Well, given that this article is already a bit dated, I still would have used a 9800 pro instead of a 5900 ultra. The GeForce FX series has yet to show potential.
Oh, and I don't know if the Athlon FX was out at this point, but if it was, I would have gone with that.

Posted on 2004-03-01 18:42:59

Jon Bach

It brings up a great point -- always check the date before you belive a hardware article :) I remember when I wrote that article -- the "Ultra" version of the GeForceFX just came out and created a lot of excitement...but it was soon shown that the 9800 still had an edge in many areas.

Posted on 2004-03-01 20:43:22

Yeah, and people should always check out more than once source before they believe what they see.
Actually, right after the 5800 ultra came out, the ONLY place that actually liked it was Tom's Hardware guide, but they are COMPLETELY partial toward nVidia and Intel. Heck, their article about the 9700 pro when it first came out was called "Pretender to the Throne".

Posted on 2004-03-02 08:19:18

Vera-Tek

I don't really think there is 1 way to make the "ultimate gaming computer".... Due to compatibility issues, preferences, etc.... But I guess there could be a basic outline, that is definetely good.

Posted on 2004-04-11 02:17:31